Vote & review builds
Your reactions shape the rankings. The more broadly you vote, the more weight each reaction carries.
Visit, then vote
The best votes come from actually visiting a guild in-game. Screenshots don't always do a base justice: hidden rooms, lighting, and atmosphere are hard to capture. Ask the builder for a tour if you can. Once you've been, react to the first post of the thread in #guild-base-showcase. See the how it works page for how votes are counted.
Check your voting spread
The more guilds you vote on, the more weight each of your votes carries in the rankings. Run /my-votes on the server to see how your reactions are distributed.
Leave feedback
Reply inside a thread with genuine feedback: what works well, what could be improved, or what inspired you. Builders appreciate detailed feedback far more than just a reaction.
Critic
The Critic role is awarded automatically by the bot to active voters who engage broadly across many guilds. Keep voting consistently and it will come. Critic reactions carry more voting weight.
Trusted Eye
The Trusted Eye role is granted by moderators to members recognized for their expertise and quality feedback. It carries even more voting weight and comes with a few guidelines to keep rankings fair.
There's no formal application: moderators sometimes reach out to members who naturally engage broadly and leave thoughtful feedback. You can also DM a moderator if you're motivated to vote fairly. There's no time commitment beyond what you'd already enjoy.
Voting on your own guild counts as a normal reaction and does not apply the Trusted Eye bonus.
Only react if you've actually looked at the screenshots and visited the guild base. No support votes.
Avoid coordinating votes with other Trusted Eyes on specific builds.
Prioritize guilds with no recognition yet. The goal is to surface hidden gems, not just reward popular builders.
What to look for
First impression
Does it immediately feel impressive or cohesive?
Creativity
Unexpected themes, layouts, or storytelling through builds.
Technique
Clever use of layering, furniture tricks, or item combinations.
Consistency
Does the style hold up throughout the base, not just in one spot?
Atmosphere
Lighting, color palette, and spatial flow.
Attention to detail
Small touches that reward a closer look.
Theme execution
How well does the build commit to and deliver on its concept?
Any question? Ping us on Discord.